IUCN: Do non-native species count as biodiversity?

Dr. Daniel Simberloff shares the importance of distinguishing between native and non-native species in biodiversity counts. 

Originally published by the International Union for the Conservation of Nature

There have been calls for biodiversity and ecosystem assessments to count non-native species as well as their native counterparts as positively contributing to biological diversity. Daniel Simberloff, Gore Hunger Professor of Environmental Studies at the University of Tennessee, member of the Invasive Species Specialist Group of IUCN’s Species Survival Commission, and Director Emeritus of the Board of Island Conservation explains why this approach is misguided and would hinder our ability to achieve international conservation and development goals.

Non-native species homogenise ecosystems and, in some instances, cause populations of native species to plummet to the point of local extinction. The true impact of non-native species on ecosystems may take time, even decades, to become obvious, by which point it is often too late to reverse negative impacts from these intruders. This presents a problem for the entire ecosystem, including the humans who rely on ecosystem services for their well-being.

“Despite the impacts of non-native species, there have been controversial calls for non-native species to be counted equally with native species in biodiversity assessments.”

According to influential international publications, such as the UN-mandated Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, humans rely on ecosystems for physical purposes (e.g. food), as well as spiritual and aesthetic reasons. Maintaining diverse ecosystems is therefore important to ensuring quality of human life.

Redonda Island before the removal of invasive species was denuded of vegetation. Credit: Ed Marshall

Despite the potential long-term impacts of non-native species, there have been controversial calls in both popular science writing (Fred Pearce, The New Wild) and in the scientific literature for non-native species to be counted equally with native species in biodiversity assessments, for example in those used to track progress towards the Aichi Biodiversity Targets of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). This negates the importance of the changes that invasive species make to ecosystem functions.

“It is misguided and potentially disastrous to consider native and non-native species as equal from the standpoint of both ecosystem services and conservation goals.”

It is misguided and potentially disastrous to consider native and non-native species as equal from the standpoint of both ecosystem services and conservation goals, including the Aichi Targets of the CBD and UN Sustainable Development Goals. The reasons are elaborated in a recent article by 26 invasion scientists from around the world, but I would like to comment on three particular issues relevant to both ecosystem services and the IUCN mission.

Firstly, the Convention on Biological Diversity – the multilateral treaty initiated in 1992 in Rio de Janeiro to conserve biodiversity and ensure its sustainable use and the equitable sharing of its benefits – suggests that humanity should value biodiversity for its “actual or potential use or value for humanity”. Article 8h specifically recognises the threat non-native species pose to this use or value. The associated Aichi Targets, adopted in Nagoya in 2010, indicate progress toward achieving the CBD goals through Target 9 – preventing and controlling alien species, and Target 12 – preventing extinction of native species by alien species. Simply including non-native species in the tally of total biodiversity produces a misleading appearance of progress toward CBD goals.

Growth of Pisonia grandis forest on Palmyra Atoll after the removal of invasive rats. Credit: Island Conservation

Secondly, if one accepts the premise that a primary purpose of biodiversity is for human use, the complex nature of biodiversity and the interactions within ecosystems are poorly understood. For the best-studied service – production of gross biomass, such as food or fibre – particular species or types of species (such as rice or wheat), rather than the total number of species, are crucial to producing the service. In addition, losing a phylogenetically distinct species because of non-native invasive species is an irrevocable loss of history that we ought to mourn in its own right, not just for the services it could have provided to humans had we saved it.

Finally, ecosystem services are not discrete – the species providing one service, like production of food, often influence the provision of other services, such as adequate supplies of clean water. It is difficult to prove that an increase in the total number of species, as opposed to sets of particular species, leads to an increase in the number of services provided. One would have to understand the contribution of all these species – native and non-native – to all ecosystem services to determine the importance of species number and species interactions for ecosystem services provision. This sort of ecological research is in its infancy and scientists cannot yet answer such questions. We cannot yet specify all the services that ecosystems provide, much less the role the interactions between species play in providing them.

“We should not delude ourselves into thinking that simply by increasing the numbers of species locally or regionally we are meeting conservation targets.”

Despite substantial progress in predicting the impact of some non-native species on ecosystem services, we are far from being able to understand which specific invaders produce devastating ecological impacts. Which invaders should we be especially concerned with? Which should we strive hardest to control or eliminate in order to achieve CBD goals and sustain important ecosystem services?

island conservation thamnoseris lacerata san ambrosio chile desventuradas

Invasive goats and rabbits drove native flora and fauna to the brink of collapse. Now free from invasive species, we are hopeful native species can recover. Credit: Island Conservation

The IUCN mission recognises the value of all biodiversity, and the IUCN Species Survival Commission strives to create “a just world that values and conserves nature through positive action to reduce the loss of diversity of life on earth.” The flood of non-native species that is homogenising ecosystems is erasing the very differences that we value and rely upon to sustain life on earth. We should not delude ourselves into thinking that simply by increasing the numbers of species locally or regionally, we are meeting international and highly important conservation targets.

By considering only native species, biodiversity assessments would more closely match the measure of biodiversity with IUCN’s mission to “influence, encourage and assist societies throughout the world to conserve the integrity and diversity of nature and to ensure that any use of natural resources is equitable and ecologically sustainable.”

Featured photo: Acteon and Gambier windy palm trees. Credit: Marie-Helen Burle/Island Conservation

About Island Conservation

Island Conservation prevents extinctions by removing invasive species from islands. To date, we have successfully restored 64 islands worldwide, benefiting 1195 populations of 487 species and subspecies. Working together with local communities, government management agencies, and conservation organizations, we select islands that have the greatest potential for preventing the extinction of globally threatened species.

View All Posts

Follow Island Conservation on Social Media

[ism-social-followers list='fb,tw,li,youtube,instagram' template='ism_template_sf_1' list_align='horizontal' display_counts='false' display_full_name='true' box_align='center' ]

[ism-social-followers list='fb,tw,li,youtube,instagram' template='ism_template_sf_1' list_align='horizontal' display_counts='false' display_full_name='true' box_align='center' ]

Midway Atoll conservation




%d bloggers like this:
Send this to a friend

size up xl male enhancement best reviews for male enhancement pills age to buy male enhancement pills man shot penis enlargement hemp seeds male enhancement penis enlarge pics using shower male enhancement enhancement pills at gas stations what drugs help erectile dysfunction x male enhancement 200 mg liquid erection pills how to increase libido while on pills extenze male enhancement warnings proplus male enhancement penis enlargement results pictures blue kangaroo male enhancement mamba sex pills for men penis enlargement surgery best in usa dog after sex pills best male enhancement at walmart what drugs are nitrates male enhancement leads best boner pill trt and penis enlargement fake cialis pills male enhancement is it possible sildenafil citrate 100mg tablets buy penis enlargement supplement sex l arginine supplement dosage natural supplement for sensitivity sex pills to make you cum more closest supplement to steroids gnc rife male enhancement male enhancement pills organic phentermine pills sex drive ultra test xr male enhancement pills how long do extenze pills take to work

weight loss without pills dopamine weight loss pill weight loss pills consumer reviews rowing diet weight loss weight loss pills womens health thrive weight loss pills price what is a natural weight loss supplement best diet plan to lose weight in a month vegetarian diet plans to lose weight fast weight loss cleansing diet diet recipe to lose weight ultimate trim weight loss pills venom weight loss supplement easy diets for women to lose weight fast diet after c section for weight loss lactose intolerance weight loss diet diet for clear skin and weight loss how to lose weight fast without pills or exercise weight loss diets for women in menopause best dietitian in delhi ncr for weight loss diabetes type 2 diet menu weight loss best weight loss diet supplements medicine that helps with energy and weight loss oatmeal diet weight loss reviews keto diet grocery list for beginners egg diet weight loss 30 day keto diet meal plan weight loss pills and weight loss surgery best diet recipes for one month weight loss effective diet for weight loss carb and diet fiber for weight loss junk food diet for weight loss how does a high fat diet cause weight loss top 10 dietary supplements for weight loss green tea pills actually help you lose weight how much vitamin c supplement for weight loss how to lose weight without pills or surgery desi diet plan for weight loss

cbd salve for pain cbd living daily tincture cbd versus hemp oil cbd oil and xanax interaction cbd oil in colorado budget accomodation melbourne cbd lyft cbd gummies can you put cbd oil in your ear high cbd low thc seeds lemon cbd oil miracle smoke cbd review do smoke shops sell cbd oil cbd coffe smart cbd shop cbd oil pancreatic cancer cbd seizure treatment how to market cbd oil cbd whole sale coffee cbd oil vitality cbd cbd emulsion cbd oil for sinus inflammation absolute cbd can you buy cbd with hsa charlottes web cbd oil discount code cbd vs rso cbd oil morning sickness cbd oil on clit zilis 7 cbd oil vapor cbd does cbd oil work for seizures methotrexate and cbd oil how is cbd oil legal cbd oil numbers how to take sublingual cbd oil cbd store tulsa cbd oil marley drug nc charlotte web cbd