Regulations or Extinction–Which Would You Choose?

A new scientific study reports that the spread of invasive species around the globe has increased in the past 200 years, indicating a need for enhanced biosecurity.

Which came first: the transportation of species around the globe or regulations on transportation of species around the globe? You guessed it–the former. Humans have been traveling with animal compatriots and surreptitious hitchhikers for much longer than biosecurity laws and procedures have existed.

The spread of invasive species has serious consequences for the environment, agriculture, and human health. One study reported approximately $97 billion in damages from 79 exotic species during the period from 1906 to 1991. Likewise, invasive species’ impacts on ecosystems can be profound, and left unchecked, lead to extinction of native wildlife. Invasive species can and do outcompete native plants and animals. Island species are particularly vulnerable–they often evolve with limited competition or threats from predators and are thus often not adapted to defend themselves against predatory invasive species such as feral cats or rats.

Policies and regulations on travel and trade have been implemented in response to the negative impacts caused by introductions. But are these regulations enough to keep up with the human activities that spread invasive species?

island conservation preventing extinctions invasive species biosecurity globalization rayadito
The Critically Endangered Masafuera Rayadito is found only on Alejandro Selkirk Island, where Island Conservation is engaged in restoration efforts. This petite bird is threatened with extinction due to the presence of invasive feral cats, rats, and mice in its habitat. Credit: Island Conservation

A new study in the scientific journal Nature Communications “No Saturation in the accumulation of alien species worldwide” reveals that current laws and regulations are not enough to slow down the rate of non-native species introductions. According to this novel study, the rate of new species introductions globally has increased in the last 200 years.

Since 1800, first records have increased constantly, only slowing during the two world wars, to a maximum of 585 in 1996.

That’s more than 1.5 records of new invasive species per day. The researchers note that the surveys of introductions are not comprehensive, meaning the actual numbers are even higher.

How do species become invasive?

Plants, pets, seeds, and wildlife are transported around the world in a variety of ways, for many different reasons, and often not on purpose. Aquatic organisms can cling to the hulls of boats or catch a ride between continents via ballast water. Potted plants can spread their seeds into new habitats when shipped internationally and they may also carry insects into new territory.

Vertebrates such as mice and rats stow away on ships and other transportation craft and are accidentally brought to even the most remote habitats (like oceanic islands), which they never would have reached without human transport systems. These represent just a few of many pathways by which organisms enter into a new habitat where they can quickly become destructive. The researchers emphasize that these pathways are always changing and being added to:

The pathways by which alien species are introduced are also changing rapidly, in particular through increased global trade, tourism, agriculture, horticulture, and the construction and formation (for example, through climate change) of new transportation corridors, such as the opening of the arctic ocean shipping routes.

island conservation preventing extinctions paul simon biodiversity days half earth threatened island biodiversity database
The Threatened Island Biodiversity Database helps conservationists track presence of invasive species and threatened species on islands around the world. Click here to learn more.

Invasive species populations continue to grow every day. For the most part, existing regulations have not been adequate to keep up with the pace of introductions, especially in the case of mammals and pathogens. One exception is the Biosecurity Act adopted in New Zealand in 1993. According to the paper, this act is the “most comprehensive and stringent national law for the prevention of alien species introductions currently in force” and has resulted in a significant decline in plant invasions.

Implementing effective biosecurity

In an era of increasing globalization and human mobility, the researchers highlight the need for immediate action:

There is an urgent need to implement more effective prevention policies at all scales, enforcing more stringent national and regional legislation, and developing more powerful international agreements.

island conservation preventing extinctions invasive species biosecurity globalization seabird
Wedge-tailed Shearwater chick. Credit: Patty Baiao/Island Conservation

New Zealand’s Biosecurity Act can serve as a model to inform development of new regulations. The distinguishing feature of the act is that it includes a list of species that are allowed into the country. This approach evidently works better than lists of banned species, which leaves room for unknown species to slip by.

Effective biosecurity offers hope for biodiversity, agriculture, and human health. Although invasive species preceded biosecurity, it’s not too late to implement strict regulations. Of course, when it comes to protecting the environment, economy, and human health from the impacts of invasive species, the sooner we take action, the better.

Featured photo: Damage to booby egg from invasive rat on Isla de la Plata, Ecuador. Photo: Rory Stansbury. Credit: Rory Stansbury/Island Conservation

Back Next

Want to learn more?

Check out other journal entries we think you might be interested in.

What is Climate Week?

Climate Week NYC: what is it and why is it important? Read on to find out why Island Conservation is attending this amazing event!

Rare Joins the Island-Ocean Connection Challenge

Rare will support the effort to restore island-ocean ecosystems by engaging the Coastal 500 network of local leaders in safeguarding biodiversity (Arlington, VA, USA) Today, international conservation organization Rare announced it has joined the Island-Ocean Connection Challenge (IOCC), a global effort to…

Video Footage Highlights Lehua Island Restoration Project

Video captures insights and hopes from the partners who are working to restore Lehua Island, Hawai’i. In 2021, Lehua Island officially became free from the threat of invasive rodents. This is a huge accomplishment that has enriched the region’s biodiversity…

Tequila Sunrise? Or Floreana Sunrise?

Carolina Torres describes how the project to restore and rewild Floreana Island signals hope for a future where people and nature can thrive together in the Galápagos.