Goats + Island Ecosystems? Not a Good Match

What happens when you add goats to an island ecosystem? Scientists break it down.

If you came across Redonda Island in the Caribbean, you probably wouldn’t think much of it. It looks like a giant, barren, good-for-nothing rock in the middle of the ocean. Maybe you’d double-take if you noticed some alarmingly skinny livestock wandering around.

But Redonda used to be a flourishing, small but vibrant ecosystem home to a variety of native plants and animals. So what happened?


Island Conservation Redonda Island

Redonda Island. Lauren Delizia/Flickr

New research looks at goats on islands
A new scientific study published in Biological Invasions, Long-term effects of feral goats (Capra hircus) on Mediterranean island communities: results from whole island manipulations” has emerged outlining the impacts of goats on Mediterranean island ecosystems. Goats that are introduced to island ecosystems will alter the natural environment by grazing native plants and trampling terrain. Invasive goats can cause a decline in soil quality and native plants, damage sensitive habitat, and disrupt food web dynamics. In fact, they have been identified as the 6th leading cause of species loss worldwide because of their impacts to vegetation.

On Redonda Island, the introduced goats ate up just about all of the island’s plants and proceeded to starve with no further food resources available. Luckily, conservation efforts are under way to save the goats and restore the island–but it’s no small task.


View from the cliffs of Spetes Island, Greece. Credit: Perdo

Why do goats pose a severe threat to island ecology?
Goats are very hardy and adaptable; they can eat tough plants—even plants with chemical defenses, require little water, have high reproduction rates, and can eat, well, a lot. To better understand and quantify the impacts of invasive goats on island ecosystems, the researchers studied 16 islands in the Aegean Sea, Greece, within a biodiversity hotspot home to variety of endemic plants (found nowhere else on Earth). They examined ecosystem changes before and after the removal of invasive goats.

Across a variety of scientific studies, goats have been found to:

  • Significantly decrease vegetation height, distribution, and biomass
  • Contribute to desertification of islands by triggering a positive feedback loop of soil movement and loss that continues even after goats are removed
  • Alter water flow due to soil changes and reduced vegetation
  • Increase populations of Diptera arthropods
  • Reduced or eliminated 77% of all plant species on the Galápagos islands
  • Compete directly with Galápagos-endemic tortoises
  • Impact breeding seabird populations

After removing goats:

  • Plant diversity continues to decline
  • Vegetation cover returns only partially due to long-term loss of soil

The study clearly demonstrates the damage invasive goats can cause on islands, and also indicates a need for continued conservation efforts—especially native vegetation restoration—on islands following their removal to support ecosystem recovery. To date, approximately 164 goat eradications have succeeded (DIISE 2015). However, how ecosystems respond to invasive goat removal varies, and more research is needed to understand how we can support native island plants and wildlife following conservation intervention.

Featured photo: Redonda Island, Carribean. Credit: Lauren Delizia

About Sara Kaiser

Sara received a BA in anthropology from UC Santa Cruz in 2014. As a freelance writer and editor, she seeks to produce and highlight stories that support ecological responsibility, body awareness, emotional intelligence, and creative action, and reveal the connections between them.

View All Posts

Follow Island Conservation on Social Media

[ism-social-followers list='fb,tw,li,youtube,instagram' template='ism_template_sf_1' list_align='horizontal' display_counts='false' display_full_name='true' box_align='center' ]

[ism-social-followers list='fb,tw,li,youtube,instagram' template='ism_template_sf_1' list_align='horizontal' display_counts='false' display_full_name='true' box_align='center' ]

Midway Atoll conservation




%d bloggers like this: