island-conservation-preventing-extinction-desecheo-butterfly-feat

Butterfly Boom on Desecheo After Decade-long Restoration Project

An outbreak of the Dingy Purplewing Butterfly was recorded on Desecheo National Wildlife Refuge, Puerto Rico following the completion of a restoration project.

Just this week the announcement came out about the successful removal of invasive rats from Desecheo National Wildlife Refuge (NWR), Puerto Rico. Removal of invasive species from islands presents an incredible opportunity for native ecosystem recovery, and this 10-year project was no exception. On our most recent visit to Desecheo NWR, a particularly exciting sign of change was apparent: a population explosion of an uncommon butterfly.

The Dingy Purplewing Butterfly (Eunica monima; Lepidoptera) appeared in massive abundance across the island, but only on the dominant tree species, Almacigo (Bursera simaruba; Burseraceae). We estimated hundreds to thousands of individual caterpillars on a single tree! These caterpillars were munching away at the leaves of Almacigo to the point that whole trees were defoliated. It was a bit concerning to see the dominant dry forest tree without leaves and we all hoped that they would survive this outbreak (we learned in later months that they did survive and recover). What impressed us the most as we trekked through the dry forest of Desecheo during this outbreak was that we could hear the sound of falling frass (insect poop) as it hit the leaf litter below—this should remind us all that even though these are small organisms, they can make up for their size in high abundances, and such events can produce whole forest or landscape change.

island-conservation-dingy-purplewing-butterfly-aaron-shiels

Dingy Purplewing Butterfly population outbreak on Bursera Simaruba trees on Desecheo Island, Puerto Rico in April 2016. Note that herbivory by larvae has left the majority of the tree canopy branches leafless (photos 1-2). Adult and abundant empty chrysalises (the casing surrounding pupa, needed to go from larva to adult) on the trunk of B. simaruba (photo 3). Adult feeding on juices from fruit (photo 4). Voucher specimen (dorsal and ventral aspects) collected from Desecheo and genetically analyzed to confirm species (photos 5-6). Collection data: USA, Puerto Rico,
Desecheo Island, 18.385437°N, 67.480044°W, 8 Apr 2016; collector: A. B. Shiels. Photo credit: William P. Haines

This was an unusual occurrence indeed! This butterfly had not been previously recorded on Desecheo Island, despite insect surveys from 1914 to 1971; it was even considered rare on the nearby Mona Island and the main island of Puerto Rico. Its native range includes the Caribbean and South and Central America, but it is only considered common in northern South America. Why did it show up now? Well, we are not sure, but we have some ideas. Yes, everyone wants to pin all new occurrences in Earth’s ecosystem to climate change, and we’ll get back to that, but it’s not our first suspicion. A distinctive possibility is that the removal of invasive rats from Desecheo Island caused the butterfly population to rapidly expand.

Why did it show up now? Well, we are not sure, but we have some ideas.

We know that invasive rats, which were recently eliminated from Desecheo NWR to restore the native ecosystem (particularly seabirds and plants), consume insects and particularly fat, slow-moving, high protein items like caterpillars—in other words the immature (larval) stage of a moth or butterfly. So, rats could have been suppressing the Dingy Purplewing Butterfly on Desecheo, and rat removal could have caused a release from rat predation, thereby resulting in a thriving population of this butterfly. The timeline for such release from rat predation fits well with what we observed and the timeline of the butterfly’s life-history.

island-conservation-preventing-extinction-desecheo-butterfly

Dingy Purplewing Butterfly (Eunica monima). Credit: Anne Toal

When we execute large-scale removals of invasive rats from island ecosystems, we expect that insects and other rat-vulnerable organisms with short life-histories will respond first to the rat removal process. Rats eat most available food items—plants and animals. However, plants and vertebrates such as seabirds, forest birds, and lizards have offspring less frequently than insects and grow from juvenile to adult stages much more slowly than insects. Thus, some of the first evidence of the negative impacts of invasive rats on ecosystems, as well as signs of recovery produced by invasive rat eradication from islands, is often observed in the insect community. But, of course, insects are not always very noticeable, and people are more likely to be interested in birds and plants than insects, so changes in insect populations following rat eradication may go unnoticed!

Some of the first evidence of the negative impacts of invasive rats…is often observed in the insect community.

island-conservation--desecheo-butterfly-desecheo-aerial

Aerial view of Desecheo Island, Puerto Rico. Credit: Tommy Hall/Island Conservation

There are alternative explanations for the explosion of Dingy Purplewing Butterflies on Desecheo. The explosion may have been a result of non-predator environmental factors (i.e., the right rainfall and temperatures caused the outbreak, and it was just happenstance with the timing of the rat eradication). Much of Puerto Rico was in severe drought during the latter half of 2015, and a day of heavy rain (3.1 cm) on Desecheo in late February and noticeable Almacigo leaf flush and overall canopy greening were documented just prior to the outbreak.  Additionally, a month after the butterfly outbreak on Desecheo, there was a large outbreak of a similar butterfly (Eunica tatila) in south and western Puerto Rico. Thus, it could have been the climate-change driven drought followed by substantial rains that triggered the butterfly outbreaks on Desecheo and the main island of Puerto Rico.

At this time, we cannot determine which of these two scenarios (or additional ones) caused the Dingy Purplewing outbreak on Desecheo. This uncertainty is one of the reasons that science, and trying to understand how the world works, is so fascinating. In fact, one of the greatest challenges in insect ecology is to determine the causes of population outbreaks; such causes are particularly difficult to identify on isolated islands where entomological and ecological surveys are infrequent or difficult to conduct. Perhaps you, or someone you know, can help solve this mystery!

Featured photo: Dingy Purplewing Butterfly. Credit: Beatrice Laporte

About Aaron Shiels

Aaron Shiels is an ecologist and research scientist with USDA National Wildlife Research Center. He received a BS in Environmental Science at University of Denver, during which a two-week course in Costa Rica got him hooked on the tropics. He received a PhD in Botany at University of Hawai’i. His interest and work in invasive species, conservation biology, and particularly the role of invasive rodents on islands stemmed from his PhD research. His family played a strong role in his love for the outdoors, as almost all of his family vacations were centered around camping, hiking, fly-fishing, and exploring the vast beauty of the Pacific Northwest where he grew up.

View All Posts
Share our mission!

Please consider sharing our website with your friends!